Today's release of some more MI5 files show a recurrent and fundamental contemporary flaw in news judgement - that a story appears in a MI5 file does not automatically make it is a news story.
The 'Nazi cyclists might be spies' story provides a classic example of this. The files release has been widely published across the media today. But this story was well know in 1937, when as the file states, a story appeared in the Daily Herald. Its certainly been recycled since. There is nothing in the MI5 file that adds anything but incidental detail to existing knowledge. The trend to sell stories from MI5 files as new is recent and growing case of churnalism.
Journalists simply do not know or ignore any prior publication of storioes in these files. Even the BBC's excellent Document radio series has a tendency to ignore previous publication. It is a dfisservice tot viewers, listeners and readers who do not know what importance to place on these overblown stories.
Released Intelligence files should only make the news if they reveal something new. But then reporters don't seem to be able to say: "There is nothing new in this document release. In fact it is boring."
The challenging stories are the ones the intelligence services do not release.
Rubicon
[ Read the rest ... ]
The 'Rubicon' blog – news on journalism practice and theory click for mission statement |
Monday 08 March 2010
Rubicon - If it is a newly released MI5 file it must be a story - not
News - Internet access is 'a fundamental right'
Internet users around the world are attracted by the availability of information Almost four in five people around the world believe that access to the internet is a fundamental right, a poll for the BBC World Service suggests. The survey - of more than 27,000 adults across 26 countries - found strong support for net access on both sides of the digital divide. Countries such as Finland and Estonia have already ruled that access is a human right for their citizens. | |
INTERNET POLL Most computers will open this document automatically, but you may need Adobe Reader |
Sunday 07 March 2010
Comment - Schools are churning out the unemployable
Saturday 06 March 2010
Lecture - Institute of Ideas
Thursday 18 March:
Claire Fox will chair the ESRC-funded LLAKES Research Centre event, Post-Recession Blues: who is being hit the hardest?, a ‘Question Time’ style debate part of the ESRC’s Festival of Social Science in London, featuring Professor Danny Dorling, Adam Lent, Anna Fazackerley, Geoff Mason, and David Willetts. 12-3pm. For reservations contact Magdalini Kolokitha.
Claire Fox will chair the ESRC-funded LLAKES Research Centre event, Post-Recession Blues: who is being hit the hardest?, a ‘Question Time’ style debate part of the ESRC’s Festival of Social Science in London, featuring Professor Danny Dorling, Adam Lent, Anna Fazackerley, Geoff Mason, and David Willetts. 12-3pm. For reservations contact Magdalini Kolokitha.
Conference - Seymour Hersh will be a speaker at the Global Investigative Journalism Conference 2010!
One of the most awarded investigative journalist, Seymour Hersh has accepted the invitation made by the GIJC 2010 to be a keynote speaker in Geneva. Known as early as 1969 to be the journalist who broke the My Lai scandal in Vietnam, Seymour Hersh has more recently exposed the Abu Graib scandal. Hersh has published eight books, including, most recently, "Chain of Command" which was based on his reporting on Abu Ghraib for The New Yorker.
It is the first time that Seymour Hersh will speak at a GIJC and he will open the morning session on Friday the 23rd April.
Do register now on www.gijc2010.ch/registration.


American jazz musician Frank Griffith's Inside Kind of Blue sextet with journalist Paul Lashmar play and discuss Miles Davis seminal 1959 album.







